The Urgency for Colleges and Universities to Operate More Like a Business Has Reached Critical Mass, New Kaufman Hall Survey Finds
Inability to roll up disparate data to a single view, lengthy budget cycles, and lagging technology top list of 2020 challenges
Note: Kaufman Hall Software is now Syntellis Performance Solutions.
CHICAGO – February 6, 2020 – While higher education financial executives feel that their sector lags other industries and should operate more like a business, only 51% of those responding to a Kaufman Hall survey said their institutions have agreed-upon key performance indicators (KPIs) used to measure and communicate financial health, up slightly from 2019 (44%). This is just one of the key findings in Kaufman Hall’s report: Higher Education Financial Trends: Priorities, Challenges and Insights to Get Ahead in 2020.
Budget and finance executives also are concerned that financial reporting and management are trending in the wrong direction — 43% of higher education institutions have budget cycles that last more than six months, up significantly from 34% in 2019. Although long budget cycles themselves are not necessarily an issue, 19% of institutions with such cycles do not reforecast throughout the year. That means budgets submitted in the fall may be out-of-date by summer, with no ability to adapt or react to current needs.
“Higher education is under a microscope more than ever before, with scrutiny around its cost, necessity, and viability,” said Kermit S. Randa, chief executive officer of Kaufman Hall Software. “To address questions about the price of a degree and whether students get a fair return as costs escalate, financial and academic leaders need better transparency into their performance and where money is going. They want to ensure every dollar is spent wisely and adopt a more businesslike approach to financial performance but our survey results show that little progress is being made toward this critical goal.”
In addition to survey findings, the report includes feedback from a panel of six higher education budget and finance professionals from Community College of Rhode Island, Lane Community College, University of Rochester, University of Arizona, and the University of Southern California, who echo Randa’s insight.
“Kaufman Hall’s report provides valuable context around the challenges and opportunities we embrace every day,” said Kim Bregenzer, chief financial officer at Dornsife College of Letters, Arts & Sciences at the University of Southern California, and a report panelist. “We are hungry for data that we can use to guide strategic plans, better understand how funds are being spent, and allocate resources to promote and support our mission. Quantifying the scope of this and other challenges helps us recognize what actions to take today and tomorrow to enrich the business of higher education.”
Using data more effectively
One of the issues facing colleges and universities is that they have been slow to adopt powerful data-driven tools and processes. Most (76%) believe that higher education technology lags other industries, down slightly from 2019’s 82%. Only 16% felt it was on par with other industries, and just 8% felt higher education leads.
When asked whether their institutions use predictive analytics to support financial planning activities, roughly 28% said yes, almost even with those who said it’s not a current objective (26%). Nearly half (47%) answered that it’s a longer-term goal, but not something they’re currently using or pursuing. Of those who said they are engaged in using predictive analytics, 94% use it to predict tuition revenue, 58% for enrollment optimization, and 52% for performance-based budgeting estimates.
When asked where they felt reporting and analysis improvement are most critical, their answers fell into three main categories: making access to accurate data easier; connecting disparate systems to enable all data to roll up to a single view; and increasing the overall ease of use to demystify the financial information that managers and staff receive.
Respondents said the top five planning and analysis initiatives to improve upon in 2020 are:
- Operational budgeting and forecasting (73%)
- Reporting and analysis to support decision-making (70%)
- Long-range financial planning (67%)
- Capital planning and tracking (51%)
- Post-award grant management (24%)
One other major concern throughout the history of the Kaufman Hall financial higher education survey has been the sustainability of the institution. The respondents felt good about their teams’ abilities to quickly and easily make adjustments to strategies and plans, with 65% saying they’re somewhat confident and 15% very confident, an overall positive sentiment increase of 17%. Only 21% said they’re not at all confident, which is down by 13% from 2019.
Additionally, when asked if current business models at their institutions were sustainable for the next five to 10 years, 60% said yes, a 26% increase over the 2019 survey. Yet given the lack of change in their approaches, there are questions as to whether this confidence might be misplaced. Making the transition to viewing all financial data in one place will be important to matching the expectation with the reality.
The third annual report is based on data from an online survey completed in September and October 2019 by budget and finance professionals from a range of higher education institutions, including four-year, two-year, public and private colleges and universities. Download a copy of Higher Education Financial Trends: Priorities, Challenges and Insights to Get Ahead in 2020.
About Kaufman Hall
Kaufman Hall provides a unique combination of software, management consulting and data solutions to help society’s foundational institutions realize sustained success amid changing market conditions. Since 1985, Kaufman Hall has been a trusted advisor to boards and executive management teams, helping them incorporate proven methods, rigorous analytics and industry-leading solutions into their strategic planning and financial management processes, with a focus on achieving their most challenging goals.
Kaufman Hall services use a rigorous, disciplined, and structured approach that is based on the principles of corporate finance. The breadth and integration of Kaufman Hall advisory services are unparalleled, encompassing strategy; financial and capital planning; cost transformation; treasury and capital markets management; and mergers, acquisitions, partnerships, and joint ventures.
Kaufman Hall software includes the Axiom Software Suite, providing sophisticated, flexible performance management solutions that empower finance professionals to analyze results, model the future, and optimize organizational decision making. Solutions for long-range planning, budgeting and forecasting, performance reporting, capital planning, and cost accounting deliver decision support, reporting, and analytics within an integrated software platform. Kaufman Hall’s Clinical Analytics empower healthcare organizations with clinical benchmarks, data, and analytics to provide a higher quality of care for optimized performance and improved patient outcomes.
Amendola Communications (for Kaufman Hall)